Sheep and Goats

Lectio Divina on Matthew 25:31-46

I remind the reader that these are not scholarly interpretations, but personal reactions in the moment. I have intentionally kept them raw. Such is the purpose of this exercise.

31 “When the Son of Man comes in his glory and all the angels with him, then he will sit on the throne of his glory.


I associate Glory with beauty, more than wealth or power. The glory of Jesus, therefore, has more to do with the beauty of his compassion. The world does not often recognize this Glory. I find that I am sometimes tempted to think that “money talks“ or “might makes right“, but that is the glory of the world, not the glory of God. I try to resist the voices that tell me empathy is toxic, or even sinful, but there are moments when I wonder whether they are right. These are not my best moments. Deep down, I do not believe that we can make the world a better place simply by killing the right people. The throne of the glory of the Son of Man, the ideal human being, is when “the power of love overcomes the love of power,“ as Jimi Hendrix said.

God, help me to honor the glory of Christ over the glory of the world. May I find beauty in compassion, not glory in wealth or victory.

32 All the nations will be gathered before him, and he will separate people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats,


Christ gathers together what the systems and ideologies of the world separate. For Christ, the only criterion of separation is how we treat the most vulnerable.

God, help me to look past the divisions and differences between the people of the world. May I “seek and serve Christ in all persons, loving my neighbor as myself” (BCP 305).

33 and he will put the sheep at his right hand and the goats at the left.

The Creeds tell us that Christ is “seated at the right hand of the Father.“ It is from this position that he rules the cosmos. His reign is characterized by compassion for the most vulnerable. It transforms the world by removing the inequalities and inequities that cause people to fight with one another. We who follow the Way of Jesus are seated there with Christ. There is power in compassion, though the world fails to recognize it.

God, open the eyes of my heart, that I may see and hold steadfastly to the way of compassion, the way of Jesus. May his law of love be the defining and ruling fact of my life.

34 Then the king will say to those at his right hand, ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world,


Like Glory, Blessed is an often misunderstood word. Those who are truly blessed are known for their works of mercy.

God, may I be blessed in the way that Jesus blesses people. May the glory of Christ be shown in my life through acts of kindness and mercy, especially for those who don’t deserve it.

35 for I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me,


Just as some people are dying of hunger or thirst, others die for want of welcome. Affection is just as legitimate a need for humans as physical sustenance. Margaret Meade pointed out that the first sign of human civilization is a broken and healed femur. This, more than evidence of tools, structures, or even fire, is the sign that our ancestors were beginning to develop communities of care that could sustain the wounded and weary. As Teilhard de Chardin wrote: “Someday, after mastering the winds, the waves, the tides and gravity, we shall harness for God the energies of love, and then, for a second time in the history of the world, man will have discovered fire.”

God, may there be “fire shut up in my bones,” as the prophet Jeremiah said; may “my heart burn within me,” like the disciples on the road to Emmaus; may a “tongue of fire rest up upon my head,” as it did for the gathered disciples at Pentecost. May my life be a Paschal Candle, burning with the light of Christ and the fire of love. May I be always conscious of this truth within me, as Scripture says in 2 Peter 1:19: “You will do well to be attentive to this as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your heart.”

36 I was naked and you gave me clothing, I was sick and you took care of me, I was in prison and you visited me.’


It is amazing just how much the concept of care gets treated like a theological heresy. The most trouble I have ever gotten in was for caring about and caring for people that were labeled as “undeserving.” it is far more common to hear the phrase, “I don’t care,“ then to hear its opposite. “Not caring” carries with it the air of invulnerability, while caring is a liability. Those who say, “I don’t care” are viewed as tough or strong. But this flies in the face of Meade’s findings. Those who care are able to do more together and build civilization stronger. It also strikes me that the word is “care for“ the sick, not heal them or fix them. The sacred duty is to care, not to fix. The “glory of the son of man,” the true beauty of the human being, is to keep caring for the person when all hope for fixing the situation is lost. Is that a foolish waste of resources? Or is it a commitment to a way of life that finds its validation in eternity?

God, help me to keep caring, even when it makes me look weak, even when there is no hope of fixing the problem.

37 Then the righteous will answer him, ‘Lord, when was it that we saw you hungry and gave you food or thirsty and gave you something to drink?


The righteous do not realize when they are fulfilling their sacred duty. They do it from the heart, because that is who they truly are. Some of the best things I’ve ever done or said were done without my knowledge of their impact. I feel ashamed to take credit for them, because it was never about me. I want to say, “That can’t be right. That wasn’t me.” If it was anyone else that I was complementing for doing the right thing, I would tell them that it takes more humility to simply accept the compliment, rather than deflect it. But it is much harder to say that when I am the one being complimented.

God, help me learn how to take a compliment. If the good I did is not about me, then let me not make it about me by refusing to accept responsibility for it. Humility gives thanks; the shadow of pride deflects.

38 And when was it that we saw you a stranger and welcomed you or naked and gave you clothing?


Nakedness is not just about exposure to the elements, it is also about respect and dignity. This too is a basic human need. The lack of respect can be a mortal wound, in many cases. There are many, who say, “If you respect me, I will respect you,” especially when it comes to unarmed black men being shot by police. But this is an equivocation of the word “respect.” In the case of the police officer, it means respect for authority; in the case of the unarmed person of color, it means respect for the dignity of human life. So, what is really being said here is: “If you do not respect my authority, I will not respect your life.“ Thus, the lack of respect for human dignity is deadly.

God, help me “strive for justice and peace among all people, and respect the dignity of every human being” (BCP 305).

39 And when was it that we saw you sick or in prison and visited you?’


Care is about showing up. So often, there are problems in the lives of my parishioners that I do not know how to solve. They ask me for answers, but I have none. I am just as lost and helpless as they are. If I could trade places with them, I would do it in a heartbeat. What I can do is visit them in the place of their pain. I can keep showing up, even when there are no answers or solutions to be found. I cannot stay with them for as long as they or I would like, because there is always someone else in pain who needs visiting. Does this verse dare me to believe that showing up, however briefly, matters anyway?

God, give me the strength to keep showing up, even when I have no answers or solutions to offer. May my love and my presence be a symbol of your unconditional love and universal presence.

40 And the king will answer them, ‘Truly I tell you, just as you did it to one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did it to me.’


Here the Lord gives us insight into the nature of reality. As Bishop Robert Barron once said, before he turned his sights to occupying the halls of power, “The word Catholic means nothing is lost.” Care for Christ in others is never wasted effort. The reality of the situation is that our service to one another is the highest form of worship. Scripture tells us, in James 1:27, “Religion that is pure and undefiled before God the Father is this: to care for orphans and widows in their distress and to keep oneself unstained by the world.”

God, help me to worship you “in spirit and in truth.” May my life be a sermon about the kind of person Jesus is. Help me to trust that none of this work is wasted, if it leads to me seeing Christ in others, and others to seeing Christ in me.

41 Then he will say to those at his left hand, ‘You who are accursed, depart from me into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels,


I don’t like the punishment language. Any religion that is coerced with the threat of violence cannot be freely chosen. If there is such a thing as “damned,” I see it in the way that an Orthodox priest once described to me: we stand eternally in the light of divine love. To some, it is paradise; to others, it is torture. Insofar as the light drives back the shadow, the darkness in me is driven away. What will be left when the darkness is gone? If there is nothing, then I will cease to exist. Perhaps the light will have complicated work to do in me. Perhaps it will be like therapy or seminary. The light of God’s love undoes all of the knots in my heart, no matter how complicated. The wheat and the tares have grown together. I am both sheep and goat. Which side do I belong on? The right hand or the left? I don’t know.

God, let me leave questions of cosmic judgment for someone much more qualified than me.

42 for I was hungry and you gave me no food, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink,


Some forms of emptiness kill quicker than others. I can go three weeks without food, three days without water, and three minutes without air. Triage is sometimes necessary, but that does not make the other needs invalid.

God, help me to discern clearly what needs must be filled first. But keep me wise enough to remember that the tyranny of the urgent does not erase the needs that can go longer.

43 I was a stranger and you did not welcome me, naked and you did not give me clothing, sick and in prison and you did not visit me.’


The never-ending torrent of need is overwhelming. There is always more that I could do, something that I am not doing. There have been times when I drove by a homeless person on the roadside, holding a sign. Times when I did not return the phone call to the church office.
Sometimes, it was because I was on my way to help someone else in need. Sometimes, it was because I was tired and simply did not have the patience to deal with it. I cannot be everywhere at once. Does that make me a failure?

God, forgive me for all the times I have failed to see you in the hurting person beside me. Grant me the strength to find a few more ounces of kindness in my heart, the wisdom to use my downtime for maximum rest and refreshment, and the faith to trust that, even though I cannot be all things to all people, you are still the “all in all“ who will provide.

44 Then they also will answer, ‘Lord, when was it that we saw you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or naked or sick or in prison and did not take care of you?’


Care is something that is taken, as well as as given. Christ gives care to me, as I take care of Christ. Every one of us has a gift to give and a need to fill. The exchange of care is a simultaneous giving and taking on both sides.

God, help me to transcend the false binary of altruism and egoism. Give me the “enlightened self-interest,“ as the Dalai Lama called it, to realize that, by helping you, I am helping myself.

45 Then he will answer them, ‘Truly I tell you, just as you did not do it to one of the least of these, you did not do it to me.’


The proof of the pudding is in the eating, as they say. St. James said, “Show me your faith apart from works, and I by my works will show you faith” (James 2:18). It is what we do that matters, not what we believe or how we feel. As Dorothy Day said, “I only love God as much as the person I love the least.” A Facebook post reads: “The true test of our faith is not how much we love Jesus, but how much we love Judas.”

God, let my faith be shown in my actions. May what I do match what I say I believe.

46 And these will go away into eternal punishment but the righteous into eternal life.”


Is life really the opposite of punishment? If if life is literal, and punishment, a metaphor, then it is a metaphor for death. If punishment is literal, and life is a metaphor, then it is a metaphor for reward. If the traditional interpretation of hell is true, even in the Annihilationist sense, then the only reward is “I won’t kill you.” It would be far better for such a God to just leave us alone. This is hardly good news commensurate with a loving God. Surely, “eternal life” must mean more than this?

God, I don’t know what to do with threats like these. Whatever happens after this life, let me live “the life of eternity” here in this world, by giving and taking care of you in others. Whatever happens next, happens. I trust you. Let’s get to work and leave the afterlife for later. There will be plenty of time to contemplate the afterlife when I’m dead.

God’s Gift to the World

Sermon for Proper 28, Year A

Matthew 25:14-30

I saw a movie several years ago, where a guy was trying to impress a woman at a fancy party. He said to her, “I don’t know how to tell you this, but I’m kind of a big deal. People know me. I have many leather-bound books and my apartment smells of rich mahogany.”

The person to whom he was talking was not nearly as impressed as he hoped she would be. Guys like this can be found in just about any part of the world, in any era of history. They talk big, look good, and they know it.

Often, people say that such men “think they’re God’s gift to women.” And you know what? They’re right!

These men are God’s gift, just not in the way that they think they are. Good looks and big bucks can get you pretty far in life, but only so far. It’s who you are that really matters, when it comes to being “God’s gift” to the world.

Today’s gospel is a story about that very thing, although its meaning is not exactly clear, at first.

Jesus’ Parable of the Talents is an odd story, at first glance. One of the things that makes it so odd is that it does not have an easily identifiable hero. In the Parable of the Prodigal Son, the father figure is obviously a symbol for our loving and forgiving God. In the Parable of the Good Samaritan, the Samaritan is a symbol for the kind of merciful person we should all strive to be. But in the Parable of the Talents, the master comes across as a greedy and vindictive mobster. How could he possibly be a stand-in for the kind of God that Jesus believes in and teaches his followers to trust?

That’s a fair question to ask. What I see as the focus of Jesus’ attention in this parable is not the figure of the master, but the relational dynamic of trust.

Each of the servants in this parable was entrusted by their master with a fortune beyond their wildest imagination. A talent, in the ancient world, was not a special skill or ability, like playing the guitar; it was an impossibly huge unit of money. A talent was worth about six thousand days’ wages, which adds up to more than sixteen years. Think about how much money you would make in that amount of time. If we take the current minimum wage in Michigan, it would add up to over $659,000. That’s just one talent.

For the servant who received two talents, that would have been more than a million dollars. For the servant who received five talents, it was more than three million dollars. Imagine being an average worker at Burger King and your manager handed you a briefcase with that much money in it! Can you blame the third servant for being more than a little intimidated at the thought of suddenly bearing the responsibility for so much money? I sure can’t!

What the third servant did, by burying the talent in the ground, was the ancient equivalent of putting the money in a safety-deposit box at the bank. It was the mature and responsible thing to do, given the circumstances.

The only problem is that keeping the money safe was not what the master wanted his servants to do.

He wanted them to make the most of the gift that he had entrusted to them.

That brings me back to the guy from the movie. His gift to the world wasn’t his fame or his leather-bound books; it was himself.

Each and every human being on this planet has been entrusted with a priceless gift, namely the gift of life itself.

Pastor A.R. Bernard says, “Life is God’s gift to us; what we do with it is our gift to God.”

Poet Mary Oliver asks, “What is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life?”

We have gathered together this morning, as we do every Sunday, to celebrate the Holy Eucharist. When we collect the offering and bring it to the altar, we are not simply taking up a collection of money to keep the lights on in the church building. In that sacred moment, we are symbolically offering our whole life back to God: our hopes and fears, our successes and failures, what we already are and what we are still becoming.

Along with the plate, we also bring up gifts of bread and wine: fruits of the living Earth that have been shaped by human labor. We offer these gifts to God, who blesses them, consecrates them, and gives them back to us as Christ’s own Body and Blood.

So then, this is the beautiful circle of life in which we participate: God gives life to us, we offer the fruits of our life back to God, and God then gives them back to us. We receive the Gifts of God as the People of God and go out to live as God’s gift to the world. This cycle repeats itself until the whole creation is eventually permeated by the presence of Christ.

Kindred in Christ, this is our mission. Each and every one of us is God’s gift to the world. We have been entrusted with the gift of “one wild and precious life.” I don’t blame anyone for feeling intimidated at the thought of being responsible for it, but what a shame it would be for us to simply bury that gift in the ground and never use it for the purpose for which it was intended.

That doesn’t necessarily mean that we have to go out and save the world or be a hero. It might just mean that we are the person to offer a safe space, a listening ear, and a kind word to a fellow human being in need. It might even start with simply taking good care of ourselves today, so that we can be of service to someone else tomorrow.

“Life is God’s gift to us; what we do with it is our gift to God.”

“Tell me, what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life?”

Enter Into The Joy

Lectio Divina is a significant part of my personal spiritual practice and sermon preparation, even though it does not always find its way into the sermon that I preach on Sunday.

I suspect that this will be one of those weeks, when my personal meditation and my final sermon go in different directions.

However, I found this meditation to be significant enough to merit sharing. As is commonly the case with Lectio Divina, this meditation is far more chaotic and less coherent than a homily. The purpose of this exercise is to foster personal engagement with the biblical text and the unconscious mind, not to offer an academic interpretation.

Disclaimer: I make no claim that what follows is a “correct” interpretation. It is simply what arose in the moment for me.

The text for this meditation is the Parable of the Talents from Matthew’s gospel (Matthew 25:14-30).

Jesus said, “It is as if a man, going on a journey, summoned his slaves and entrusted his property to them; to one he gave five talents, to another two, to another one, to each according to his ability.

Much has been trusted to me, both in my family, and in my ministry. I sometimes feel overwhelmed and have imposter syndrome. I think there must have been some mistake, because I am not worthy or capable of this. I sometimes feel envious of those who seem to be so much more put together than I am.

God, help me to trust the trust that you have placed in me. When I feel overwhelmed, help me remember that I am not here by accident or mistake, but because you have called me and will provide everything I need.

Then he went away.

God often seems distant. I prefer to hedge my bets with philosophy. Yet, even my doubts, bring me back around to believing in a God that is within everything. I cannot seem to let go of the idea of God, even when I am trying to act like an atheist.

God, help me to trust in your presence within all things and working through me. Help me remember that there is no “away” for you, for you fill all things.

The one who had received the five talents went off at once and traded with them, and made five more talents.

The courageous servant had no hesitation, but eagerly went out to risk and to experiment. The willingness to do this is a mark of faith.

God, give me a faith that is willing to try new things, to experiment, and to take risks creatively for the benefit of your people.

In the same way, the one who had the two talents made two more talents.

We are inspired and learn from the examples of others who have gone before us. I think particularly of Rich Mullins and Bob Ekblad in my own life.

God, help me to gain ideas from others who have gone before. Let me not seek to imitate or re-create their work, but use it to inspire my own unique work.

But the one who had received the one talent went off and dug a hole in the ground and hid his master’s money.

I often dig myself into a hole with self-doubt. I want to hide and be safe. I run from the risks.

God, help me to recognize when I am digging a hole for myself, and trying to hide in it. Help me be honest about it, about where I might need to do it temporarily, and also have the courage to leave it behind when the time comes for me to move on.

After a long time the master of those slaves came and settled accounts with them.

Just as God is not distant in space, God is also not distant in time. All of time and space are one eternal “here and now” with God. This too is about recognizing the presence of the divine in everything and everything in the divine.

God, help me to live in the eternal now, the fountain of all blessings and creativity, from which all things derive their being.

Then the one who had received the five talents came forward, bringing five more talents, saying, ‘Master, you handed over to me five talents; see, I have made five more talents.’

Faith brings its partial results, with the same courage that let it out to risk and to experiment.

God, help me to celebrate the partial results that my efforts bring, trusting that even an incomplete good is still good and further inspiring the ongoing work of others.

His master said to him, ‘Well done, good and trustworthy slave; you have been trustworthy in a few things, I will put you in charge of many things; enter into the joy of your master.’

The universe is expanding and growing in complexity and consciousness, as Thomas Berry and Teilhard de Chardin have noted.

God, help me to recognize and participate in this expanding universe, which is growing in complexity and consciousness, as it develops in Christogenesis.

And the one with the two talents also came forward, saying, ‘Master, you handed over to me two talents; see, I have made two more talents.’

The word for “handed over” also means “tradition” in Greek.

God, help me to honor the living tradition that has been passed down to me. Help me to keep it alive and help it to move into its evolutionary future, taking on every new forms of life in this expanding universe.

His master said to him, ‘Well done, good and trustworthy slave; you have been trustworthy in a few things, I will put you in charge of many things; enter into the joy of your master.’

Joy is a journey, not a destination.

God, help me to enter more fully into your joy. Give me the eyes of Faith, to see your wonders with my heart, and to participate in the unfolding journey of the universe.

Then the one who had received the one talent also came forward, saying, ‘Master, I knew that you were a harsh man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you did not scatter seed; so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground.

I sometimes forget to look at my small part in the context of the whole. I give credit to my ego, when I am actually “the product of the love of thousands,” as some poet once said.

God, help me to remember that it is you who is doing all of these things in me. There is nothing sown that you have not sown.

Here you have what is yours.’

I try to compartmentalize my life, dividing it into sacred and secular, mine and yours.

God, help me to overcome my ego consciousness, which tries to divide everything into private property. What is yours as everything, including me and all that is mine.

But his master replied, ‘You wicked and lazy slave!

My impulse to hide in self protection, and claim as private property my small crumbs of the universe, this is the root of all evil. It is folly and illusion.

God, bring me back to the truth, that all things live, move, and have their being in you. I pray as we do at the offertory in our liturgy: “all things come of thee, O Lord, and of thine own, have we given thee.”

You knew, did you, that I reap where I did not sow, and gather where I did not scatter?

There are so many ridiculous things that I think I know. My small minded image of God is really a form of self limitation. I make it up to justify my fear, my hiding, and my selfishness.

God, help me to question what I think I know, and to adopt an ever-expanding image of you, the universe, and myself, which are all ultimately one thing.

Then you ought to have invested my money with the bankers, and on my return I would have received what was my own with interest.

Regret is a wonderful teacher.

God, help me to learn from the past, including my own mistakes, and imagine new and better ways to live with creativity and courage and compassion, for the future.

So take the talent from him, and give it to the one with the ten talents.

What really matters is the exchange within the flow of the universe. It is like the episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, where they explain how Ferengi religion works. The flow and the exchange reminds me of the Tao, Perichoresis, and Kenosis in the Trinity.

God, help me to be aware of the dynamic flow of energy within the relationships of relationships, within the universe. May all beings and all relationships be consciously welcomed as participants in the eternal network that is you.

For to all those who have, more will be given, and they will have an abundance; but from those who have nothing, even what they have will be taken away.

When I look at myself and the universe through the eyes of Faith, I see an overflowing of abundance and beauty. On the other hand, there is a hilarious irony that those who have nothing will have nothing taken away from them, therefore they lose nothing. What they then have at the end is nothing, which is exactly what they started with. So nothing is lost, but everything is transformed when it is brought into the network of the whole. We could say that “nothing changes“, not in the fatalistic sense but in the literal sense, because nothing becomes everything. It is like the raindrop falling into the ocean. “And they will have an abundance.”

God, give me the eyes of Faith to see my nothing in the context of your everything, so that I might behold the abundance.

As for this worthless slave, throw him into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.’”

Death is an inescapable fact of life. I can try to make myself eternal, but will never succeed, so long as I continue to mistake my part for the whole. This last sentence is scary, because I am accustomed to associating it with punishment and hell. But if it is simply a statement about the fact of mortality, it can hit quite differently. The self-limiting way of the third slave leads inevitably to this. Individual survival is always an illusion and a losing battle.

God, help me learn to identify myself with the universal network of relationships, where the abundant life of the whole can never be quenched, and I am never alone.

Carry the Light

Sermon for Proper 27 A

Matthew 25:1-13

On October the 22nd, 1844, there was a group of people who were expecting something very, very big to happen. They were known as the Millerites, and they believed that they had figured out the exact day of the second coming of Christ.

And so they had prepared themselves in every way conceivable, selling possessions, quitting their jobs, gathering in prayer and waiting for the end of the age to come upon them. And then October the 22nd, 1844, came and went. And October the 23rd dawned like any other day will.

This became known among them as the Great Disappointment. I don’t want to make fun of them too hard, because they were waiting in faith for the fulfillment of all that Christ had promised: for the world to be set right, for every tear and sadness to be wiped away, as it says in the Scripture.

These were people who lived in hope, mistaken though they were about the exact time and date. I think all of us can relate to the Great Disappointment in some way or another. We have experienced disappointments of our own when we’ve been awaiting test results, or when we’ve been faithfully praying through mending a broken relationship that doesn’t work out, or when we’ve been out there doing the hard work of getting an education and looking for a job and it’s not materializing.

Sometimes when we just watch the news and we see this world that is the way it is, rather than the kind and gentle world that Jesus envisions for us, we too can understand disappointment.

And that’s what today’s Gospel brings us into. Jesus tells the story of these ten bridesmaids who have an important job as part of the wedding ceremony: Their job is to carry the light. Back then, if you recall, there were no street lamps or flashlights.

It’s hard to find your way in the dark, so you need people who carry torches, who walk with you and ahead of you to light the way to where the celebration begins. The bridesmaids, in addition helping the couple to celebrate, also serve a practical function in weddings in the ancient world.

On this particular occasion, the bridegroom is late and things are not going according to schedule. All of the bridesmaids fall asleep, which I think is a very interesting detail. No matter how faithful or how wise you are, everybody needs a nap sometime.

In the midst of the waiting, the time stretches on, the light grows dim, and finally, unexpectedly, they hear the shout at midnight that the bridegroom is coming.

The time is at hand. And there’s the five wise bridesmaids who have brought extra oil for their lamps, and the five foolish bridesmaids who did not. And the foolish bridesmaids say to the wise ones, “Give us some of your oil!”

The wise ones say, “No, we can’t. There won’t be enough.”

Jesus tells the story in this way to underscore the seriousness of the commitment that he’s talking about. Symbolically, he is talking about how prepared we are (or not) for the fulfillment of God’s promises in this world. We are still waiting, after 2,000 years.

While the wise bridesmaids were unable to share their oil, there was something else that I think maybe they could have shared: their light. I wonder: what if the foolish bridesmaids had not gone into town to find a late-night oil dealer, what could have happened instead?

If they had stayed with the wise bridesmaids and shared their light, there would not have been the danger of running out of oil. Then everyone would have made it to the celebration on time.

The wise ones couldn’t share their oil, just as we cannot give our personal faith to someone else, but we can share the light that we carry with us.

It makes me think of the pandemic, when we were all locked down, social distancing, and so many things were shut.

My family and I were holed up in our house, like most were. After a while, one of my neighbors had an idea. She said, “Could we gather outside, and social distance, just to be able to see one another’s faces?”

That’s what we ended up doing. On Tuesday night, everyone came over to our backyard. We stayed the six feet apart and ordered pizzas (we socially distanced the pizzas too).

It didn’t make the pandemic go any faster. It didn’t resolve the global crisis we were experiencing, but it helped us to share one another’s lives.

It was a comfort to us. It gave us strength and hope. It was a really sacred time that we had on those Tuesday nights.

There was no church service. It was just pizza and conversation from six feet away. Even in the darkest of times, we were able to share our lives with each other.

We Christians, as people of faith, have an opportunity to share our lives with one another. What that asks of us is that we trim our lamps and keep our oil stocked. That’s an analogy for our spiritual practices and good works. That’s what keeps the light of faith burning within us.

But it’s also true that each of us is only human, so our individual light can’t burn perpetually. Every now and again, the light within us gets a little dim, because we all have tough days.

That’s when we can lean on each other, to borrow some of the light.

We can’t borrow the oil, but we can borrow the light.

If I’m really honest, there’s a little bit of the wise bridesmaid and the foolish bridesmaid in me at all times.

There are some ways in which my oil is fully stocked and my light is burning brightly.
At the same time, there are parts of my life where it’s not burning so brightly, so I need to lean on someone else. I need to ask for help.

That’s okay. Because the good news is that the wedding is not canceled, even though it’s delayed. The celebration is still coming.

If we can do our part to hold on, keep our lamps lit, and ask for help when our lamps grow dim, then we have a better chance of making it through the dark of life’s great disappointments.

This is the gift that God gives us: The gift of each other. The gift of the light that is within us. There are so many ways that we can share gift.

Here in our church, we also have The Book of Common Prayer.

This book is one of the ways that the church is able to carry the light for us when our own hearts grow dim. This collection of prayers and liturgies, some of which are hundreds or even thousands of years old, help us to find the words to pray when we can’t think of the right words.

Some days, I come to church and can pray every single one of those words from the bottom of my heart. Some days, I’m tired and barely making it through. But the words of our liturgy sustain me. It’s a gift that can sustain all of us as well.

The promise holds true: the celebration is still coming. We don’t know how long we have to wait, but we know that the darkness will not have the last word.

So, let’s hold on to the light and hold on to each other.

Radical Amazement

Sermon for Proper 24, Year A

Matthew 22:15-22

“Render unto Caesar those things that are Caesar’s, and to God those things that are God’s.”

Familiar words. They are frequently cited as a reference to the separation of church and state. There’s only one slight problem with that: Separation of church and state are not what Jesus was talking about.

In Jesus’ time, there was no separation of religion and politics, where Caesar had the political sphere, God had the religious sphere, and they both staid in their respective lanes. Religion was a political affair, as we can see in the complicated relationships that happened with the religious leaders, living under occupation by the Roman Empire. Also, politics was religious, especially insofar as Caesar himself claimed to be “the Son of God.”

The concept of separation of church and state is a modern one and a good one. I wholeheartedly support it, because it protects the church from the state and the state from the church, but it’s not what this passage is about.

We default to old habits, like associating this passage with the separation of church and state, because it’s easier to let challenging questions can become comfortable answers. And that’s pretty similar to what is actually happening in today’s Gospel.

Richard Rohr is a spiritual writer who said, “Religion is, ironically, often the safest place to hide from God.”

It seems counterintuitive. We ask, “Isn’t religion how I connect with God? I come to church, receive the sacraments, read the Bible to hear from God, and pray for guidance from God.”

But sometimes, speaking only for myself, I read the Bible, not to learn and grow, but to prove that I’m right.
And sometimes I pray, not because I’m looking for guidance, but because I’m looking for permission.
Sometimes I listen to someone I disagree with, not to understand that person’s perspective, but so I can make up my next argument in advance.
And sometimes I ask questions, not to explore the truth more deeply, but to set a trap for someone else. That’s exactly what the Pharisees and Herodians were doing to Jesus in today’s Gospel.

The trap starts with flattery. They say, “Teacher, we know that you are sincere, that you teach the Word of God in truth, and you show deference to no one. So tell us, is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor or not?”

This was a question to which there was no good answer. If Jesus had said, “no, don’t pay taxes to the emperor,” then they could say, “Aha, we’ve got you! You are causing sedition and treason. You are trying to rise up against Rome, so we can get Pontius Pilate to come and kill you.”

But if he had said, “Yes,” then they could say to their Jewish neighbors, “See? He’s not really one of us!”

If Jesus had said Yes or No, it would have been a bad answer, but Jesus is a pretty smart guy. He sees what they’re doing and calls out their hypocrisy.

Hypocrisy, in this case has a very specific definition. It’s not just somebody who fails to live up to their ideals. Because that applies to every single one of us in this room.

In this case, the Pharisees and Herodians are hypocrites because they are telling the truth in the service of a lie. They are not interested in seeking truth; they’re interested in what they think the truth can do for them. They’re using the truth. That’s the hypocrisy that Jesus is calling out in today’s gospel.

He says, “Okay, I’ll play. Show me the coin used for the tax.”

So they bring him the coin. He holds it up and says, “Whose image is this?”

And they say, “It’s Caesar’s image.”

That’s the moment when Jesus reversed the trap on them. Caesar’s face was on the coin, but Caesar himself, as a human being, was made in God’s image. So, whose image was really on that coin? God’s. That’s how Jesus exposed their hypocrisy.

Jesus demonstrated how the religious authorities were failing to recognize the image of God. So, when He says, “Render unto to Caesar what is Caesar’s,” He is really saying, “Let Caesar have this silly little coin if he wants it, but give to God what is God’s.”

What belongs to God?
You. Me. Everything. The universe.

That’s how Jesus avoids their trap and exposes their hypocrisy for what it is. The coin may bear Caesar’s image, but Caesar himself, along with you, me, and everyone else, bear God’s image. Jesus exposed the hypocrisy of the religious authorities, but the good news is that he keeps engaging with them.

He keeps posing these uncomfortable questions in order to get them to look below the surface fights over religion and politics. He says, “I want you to see the presence of God in all of this.” That is true spiritual insight.

When we look at the world through those eyes, we discover that we don’t have to craft a fancy image for ourselves. Because we already bear the image of God. We don’t have to earn it, and we can’t lose it. No matter how good or how bad we are, as persons, the Imago Dei is simply there.

And so Jesus, yes, does expose their hypocrisy, but the good news is that exposure does not lead to rejection, but healing.

I experienced a little bit of that this week while I was preparing this sermon.

I started reading and praying through the text, like I usually do, and I was thinking about all the people I don’t like. I thought, “They’re all hypocrites with ulterior motives!” I was going to come up with all kinds of witty examples to prove their hypocrisy.

But then I started looking a little deeper. I stopped looking at their motives and started looking at my own. I was crafting a sermon that was all about pointing the finger at “those hypocrites over there,” so I was falling into the same trap that the Pharisees and Herodians fell into.

Sometimes, when I’m reading an article, I check to see whether the author is part of my ideological “club.”

Sometimes, I assume the negative intentions of another person before I’ve really heard them out.
Sometimes, like the Pharisees and Herodians in this passage, I might technically tell the truth about something, but do it in a misleading way. It might be true to the letter of the truth, but not to the spirit of the truth.
I came to this passage, looking to point my finger at people I don’t like, but I ended up pointing at myself. That was painful, but it was also healing.

Because, even in that mistake that I was making, I was still loved. I am still made in the image of God.
All the people I love are still made in the image of God.
All the people I don’t like are still made in the image of God.
And that’s true, whether I want to admit it or not.

But if I can embrace that truth, I can grow, even though that growth is sometimes painful.

What it requires is that I have the humility to admit when I’m wrong and the courage to see the image of God in someone with whom I disagree.

When Jesus presented these questions and exposed the hypocrisy of the Pharisees, the text tells us that they were “amazed.”

Amazement is amazing. Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel said, “To be spiritual is to be amazed.”

For a brief moment, Jesus’ question opened up their horizons, giving them an opportunity to look deeper, to see the true meaning of who they are, and experience the true meaning of their lives in this world.

The tragedy is that they were not willing to stay that amazement.
The text says, “When they heard this, they were amazed; they left him and went away.”
That’s a tragedy for them and a warning for us.

We occasionally will have moments where tough questions are able to open our minds and hearts. If we can stay in that moment of radical amazement, letting the questions break us open, then the possibility of transformation begins.

We have an opportunity to see the presence and image of God in ourselves and in everyone around us: The inherent beloved-ness, “the dignity of every human being,” as we say in our Baptismal Covenant.

What this opportunity requires of us is that we stay in the difficult questions long enough to be amazed, and stay in the amazement long enough to be changed.

As you go out into this week, I encourage you to be open to the challenging questions that come your way. Be open to radical amazement at the most ordinary things. Let that amazement change you from the inside out, so that you can know yourself, and everyone else, to be utterly unique reflections of the image of God.

Grace Is Free, Not Cheap

Sermon for Proper 23, Year A

Matthew 22:1-14

Okay, so that was a really tricky parable! It’s pretty high on my list of “things I wish Jesus had not said.”

At first glance, it looks like a story about a violent megalomaniac who murders people for declining a wedding invitation, and then has his troops go out into the city and bring a bunch of random people in, but then kicks one of them out because he didn’t happen to be wearing a tuxedo that day.

If this doesn’t sound fair to you, don’t worry, you haven’t missed the point. It means that you’re paying attention.

This is a parable that requires quite a bit of unpacking, but lucky for you, you just happen to have a resident Bible nerd to do it. So let’s jump right in.

Jesus spoke this parable during Holy Week, where our gospel readings have been for the last several weeks.

In the reading that we heard last week, we heard the parable of the wicked tenants, who would not give the vineyard owner the fruits of the harvest when the time came. And when the vineyard owner sent his servants to collect that produce, they beat them up, mistreated them, and killed them. Finally, they did the same to his own son.

You can see the parallel between last week and this week. The king’s servants sent out to deliver the invitation to the wedding were also beat up and killed by those who did not want to accept the invitation. Their rejection came with violence. The king then answers with even greater violence.

This is one of those areas where a parable is not exactly an allegory, so it’s not just that the king symbolizes God, therefore everything the king does is what God would do. That’s not how parables work. I think we can see this quite plainly because, at the end of Holy Week, Jesus will be rejected and killed by the established authorities, but he does not return violence for violence. Instead, he prays for the ones crucifying him, saying, “Father, forgive them.”

The world answers violence with more violence, but Jesus shows us another way.

The really remarkable thing about this parable is that, after this initial rejection of the invitation, the wedding feast still goes on. The invitation is then extended to the people in the streets, far and wide, “both good and bad.” Everyone is welcome here.

The elites turned down the invitation, but the common people accepted it. Nobody there earned their seat at the table. They just happened to be in the right place at the right time. They’re at the feast because grace made room for them.

Jesus is creating a community that is a sanctuary, a place that is safe from the ongoing power struggles in the world today. In his feast, belonging is given rather than earned.

But then, we have this coda at the end of the parable, where a guest is kicked out for not wearing a wedding robe.

Why would the king expect a random guy from the neighborhood to be dressed in a tuxedo, if he was just on his way to the grocery store?

This is where the parable is more metaphorical story than party planning advice. This character has accepted the invitation to the party, but refused to participate in the celebration.

Here is a modern equivalent: I’d like you to imagine a wedding where the mother of the groom disapproves of the bride, so she comes to the wedding dressed as if she was going to a funeral: black dress, black veil, head cast down, weeping tears of grief. It would be pretty clear to everyone that she was sending a message with the way she was dressed. She’s saying, “I’m physically present, but I am not joining this celebration.”

I think the same thing is true of this man who did not have a wedding garment. He is deliberately choosing to reject the meaning of the celebration. Jesus ends the parable by discussing some rather stark consequences for this rejection.

The king says, “Bind him hand and foot and cast him into the outer darkness where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth.”

Jesus follows up with, “For many are called but few are chosen.”

I don’t think this warning is about hellfire or damnation. I think this is about the danger that we face when we show up to the celebration in the Church of Christ, but refuse to participate in that celebration.

Grace is free, but it is not cheap.

This story is more familiar to me personally than I would like to admit. When I was in seminary, I had very high academic ambitions.

I planned to get a PhD, write many important books, and have one of those tweed blazers with the patches on the elbows. I wanted to prove that I was the smartest person in the room, so I tried to dominate every classroom discussion and get the professor’s attention.

My girlfriend at the time was disturbed when she saw this behavior. She said, “This is not who I know you to be.”

There was a second problem with my strategy for being the smartest person in the room:
Namely, that I was not in fact the smartest person in the room.

There was always someone who was just a little bit smarter than me, a little bit quicker with their response, and a little bit better at playing academic politics with the right professors.

I was getting really frustrated, and I began to question whether an academic career might not be the right place for me, after all. I asked my roommate one night, “Do you think that maybe ordained ministry might suit me better than a career in the academy?

He laughed in my face and said, “I think just about anything would!”

I thought my problem was that I was losing the game of academic competition. But I realized later that the real problem was the game itself.

I was turning seminary into another contest for recognition.
I was turning theology into another way to win.

But Jesus was offering me something much, much better.

That, I think, is what the symbol of the wedding garment is really about.

In his letter to the Colossians, St. Paul encourages the people to clothe themselves with compassion, kindness, humility, patience, and above all, love. This is the clothing of a follower of Christ. This is what it looks like when someone participates in the gracious celebration of the community that Christ has created.

If you’re going to come to the party, you need to dress for the party.

You don’t need money or status.
You don’t need a spotless past.
You don’t need to prove that you earned your spot there.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer famously wrote, “When Christ calls a man (sic), he bids him come and die.”

Sometimes, the thing that needs to die in us is that need to win, dominate, and be right. To make other people smaller than we are.

We think of grace as a lovely and feel-good concept, but the fact is that grace is very offensive.

It offends us twice:
First, it offends us because it lets in the people that we think don’t belong there. The people who don’t look like us, think like us, pray like us, vote like us, or love like us. The people we’d rather not have in the room.

The second way that grace offends us is that it asks us to give up those struggles for power and one-upmanship that made us think that we belong more than those other people.

Grace is free. But it’s not cheap.

What grace costs us is the power struggle that we thought we needed in order to have a place at the table.
Because we don’t earn a place at God’s table.
Grace gives it to us.

God Is Not In Competition With Us

Sermon for Proper 22, Year A

Matthew 21:33-46

God is not in competition with us.

I talk about my kids a lot. When I do, I say, “my kids,” which makes sense because that’s how we’re used to talking. But the thing is: they’re not really my kids, in the same way that my books or my car belong to me.

They’re not my possession. They are their own, independent, strong-willed, intelligent people. And the older they get, the more I realize that they’re going to have their own likes and dislikes, as well as their own opinions (which they are very happy to voice).

I have a responsibility to love and care for them, but at the end of the day, it is their life, not mine. I’m their parent, not their owner.

We use possessive language over a lot of things in this world. We talk about my time, my life, my family, my church, my country.

But there’s a danger there: We can forget that we do not, in fact, own time, life, our families, the church, or our country. They don’t belong to us. Nevertheless, we care about them, we are responsible for them, and we love them.

That mistaken identity between stewardship and ownership lies at the heart of today’s Gospel. We hear this story that Jesus tells about these tenants in a vineyard. The owner of the vineyard builds the watchtower, plants the vineyard, sets everything up, and leases it out to them.

They care for it as they’re supposed to. But somewhere along the way, they start to get the idea that it’s their vineyard. And they start acting accordingly.

When harvest time comes, the landowner sends various servants to collect the landowner’s portion of the produce, and the tenants treat those servants with increasing levels of violence: beating them, killing them, and stoning them. Finally, the owner says, “I will send them my son. Surely, they will respect him.”

But that’s not what happens. They kill the son too, thinking that if they kill him, then they’ll get the inheritance. Which doesn’t really make sense, if you know how inheritance laws work. It just shows you how possessiveness and violence can twist our thinking into some really foolish directions.

I can relate to that on a personal level. I notice that, when I feel threatened, I start using language about “taking things back.” I want to “take back my family,” “take back my church,” or “take back my country.” That language gives me away. Because, when I say “take back,” I am implying that I think it was mine to begin with.

If I’m feeling particularly spiritual, I might say, “I’m not taking it back for me, I’m taking it back for God.” But here’s the thing: God never lost it in the first place. God is not in competition with us.

If I say, “I’m going to take this or that thing back for God,” God never lost it, so that doesn’t make sense.
If I say, I’m “taking it back,” it was never mine to begin with, so that doesn’t make sense.
Which means that, in the end, I’m just taking.  

I am willing to use force and violence to perpetuate the illusion of ownership over whatever it is that feels threatened in my life.

Jesus exposes this tendency in today’s parable.
And there’s something very subtle in his response to the people:
At the end, Jesus asks a question, as he often does.

He asks, “What do you think the owner will do to these tenants?”

And they respond, “He will put those wretches to a miserable death.”

Did you notice who gave that answer? Was it Jesus who said that? No. It was the religious leaders that he was talking to.

This scene takes place during Holy Week. The tension between the Jesus movement and the established temple institution is coming to a head. In the midst of this tension, Jesus tells this parable about them, implying that they are the tenants who have mistaken their stewardship for ownership. And the other mistake they make is assuming that God is just as violent as they are.

What Jesus actually does is ask another question. Basically, he asks, “Have you guys never read the Bible, where it says that ‘the stone the builders rejected has become chief cornerstone; This is the Lord’s doing, and it is amazing in our eyes’?”

Jesus doesn’t agree with “putting the wretches to a miserable death.” For Jesus, God is in the business of building, not tearing down. For Jesus, “that which has been rejected is now the cornerstone.” They are the bringers of death, but God is the bringer of life.

It’s not a mistake that this conversation is happening during Holy Week. At the end of this week, Jesus the Son of God, is going to be taken outside of the vineyard, Jerusalem, and crucified. And then on Easter Sunday, will be raised from the dead. Thus, showing how God brings life, not more violence. God is not in competition with us.

When my wife was a little girl, her parents had a particular prayer that they prayed for her: They prayed that she would have more faith than they do.

What I love about that prayer is that they’re not praying that she would believe what they believe. They weren’t praying that she would grow up to be exactly like they are, or that she would never change, or that they could always control her. They prayed that she would go beyond where they would go.

This is a wonderful image of stewardship. It is an open-handed holding of what has been entrusted to them. They loved her without possessing her. That’s what being a good tenant of God’s vineyard looks like.

Open hands don’t mean idle hands. We still have a responsibility to care for that which has been entrusted to us. We have a duty to protect that which is vulnerable.

But we do so while recognizing this life belongs to God, and God is perhaps guiding it in ways that we can’t see. Maybe that’s also true of our churches, of our country, and of our very lives.

Because at the end of the day, God is the owner of the vineyard, not us. And God holds everything with those open hands, including us.

Don’t Be A Christian

Sermon for Proper 21, Year A

Matthew 21:23–32; Philippians 2:1–13

“Don’t be a Christian.”

That’s probably a bit of a weird thing to hear from your priest on Sunday morning, so I’m going to unpack that a little bit.

Don’t be a Christian. Be Christ.

There is an occupational hazard of my job: it is part of my job to know all of the Christian lingo really well. But the issue is that you can know all of the right Christian lingo, and it still doesn’t change your heart.

It reminds me a little bit of a friend of mine who got really interested in the guitar. So he went online and researched guitars. He bought a book on guitars and read it. He learned all about the history, how they were made, and what the different good guitar companies were.

The only thing he never did was buy a guitar and learn how to play it.

Which kind of defeats the purpose, doesn’t it?

In the same way, there was a philosopher in Denmark in the nineteenth century named Søren Kierkegaard. He lived in a culture that was very nominally Christian. Almost everyone around him considered themselves Christian because, well, they were Danish. Denmark was predominantly a Lutheran country.

Most people were baptized, grew up there, went to church, but there was never necessarily a time within that when a person made a sincere leap of faith, a commitment to becoming a follower of Christ.

And for Kierkegaard, that was an issue.

Jesus encounters a similar process today in our gospel reading.

To set the stage a little bit, this passage that we just read comes immediately after the cleansing of the temple. So this is Holy Week, the last week of Jesus’ life. And Jesus, the day before, had gone in and caused quite a ruckus in the temple and disrupted all the normal proceedings.

The religious authorities are quite understandably disturbed and thinking, We’ve got to regain control of this situation.

So they come up with a plan to trap him. They go up and say, “By what authority are you doing this?” Because they know that he is not one of these students trained in one of their schools.

And they also know that if he claims his own authority, then it’s meaningless. And if he claims God’s authority, then he’s blaspheming.

So there’s no good answer.

They think they’ve got him.

But Jesus, as he usually does, responds to their question by asking another question, telling a story, and then asking another question after that.

So first, the question.

He says, “The baptism of John—by what authority did John baptize?”

And the religious authorities come up with a really brilliant strategic flowchart in that moment.

They think, Okay, here are our two options. If we say it was from heaven, that it was from God, then he’ll say, ‘Why didn’t you believe him?’ And if we say that it was of human origin, then the whole crowd is going to be mad at us because they think John was a prophet.

So there’s not really a good answer for them now.

They opt for the safe answer and say, “We don’t know.”

Jesus says, “Okay.”

And that’s when he starts to tell the story of a man with two sons.

He says to both of them, “Go and work in the vineyard today.”

The first one says, “No, I don’t want to.”

Which is pretty disrespectful. It’s the wrong answer.

But later on, he changes his mind, and he ends up going.

Then the father goes to the second son, and the second son gives the right answer:

“Oh yes, sir. Of course. I’ll go.”

But the problem is, he never actually goes.

And that’s when Jesus comes to the next question that he asks all of them.

He says, “Which of the two did the will of his father?”

Well, obviously, it’s the first one.

It’s not the one who said the right thing. It’s the one who did the right thing.

And that is a disturbing thing for us as religious people, because we’re very good at putting our Christian labels on things.

We can put them up on billboards and on T-shirts. We can put the Ten Commandments on every wall in the country.

But what good is that really going to do if we’re not putting those same commandments in our hearts and following them ourselves as the people who claim to be Christian?

Christianity is more than just branding.

The whole point is to take the words that are in our mouths and let them sink into our hearts, and then move down from there into our hands and feet so that they actually change the way we live in the world.

That’s where the phrase that Paul uses becomes really relevant in the reading that we heard just now.

He says, “Let the same mind be in you that was in Christ Jesus.”

He’s talking about the mind of Christ.

Let the life of Christ become your life.

That same self-giving love. That same refusal to cling to status. That willingness to serve others and show kindness to others.

To be the kind of person that Jesus was—that is the goal.

Not to wear the Christian T-shirts or have the bumper stickers on our cars.

It’s to be like Christ.

“Let the same mind be in you that was in Christ Jesus.”

The one who actually went into the vineyard is the one who did the will of his father, not the one who said he was going to go.

That can raise all kinds of uncomfortable questions for us, because what if there are people around us, in this world and in our community, who do not consider themselves Christians and yet are better Christians than us?

I think particularly of Mahatma Gandhi, who said, “I like your Christ, but I don’t like your Christians. They are so unlike your Christ.”

Gandhi was a man who did not carry the label Christian.

But in so many important ways, he did bear the mind of Christ.

Let the life of Christ become your life.

Go work in the vineyard.

Don’t be a Christian.

Be Christ.