Sermon for Easter 4, Year A
Psalm 23 is one of the most well-known passages of religious literature in the world, from any religious tradition.
It’s comforting. And so we often read it at funerals. We cross-stitch it onto nice, fluffy pillows. And it’s one of those passages that we kind of take for granted. We hear it several times a year—that’s what many of us do—and we don’t really continue to think about it.
But I’d like to change that today.
I’d like to take a closer look at it. And it might help to keep your bulletins open to it so that we can really internalize these words. Our psalm is on page six—we just sang it together a few minutes ago.
We’re going to go through this and take a closer look at why this psalm is so comforting, and why it speaks both to our ancestors in the past and can still speak to us today.
So let’s start right now.
In this first verse, “The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not be in want.”
That word “want” is really interesting. It’s the same word that was used in the Torah, in Deuteronomy chapter 2, verse 7, when Moses is talking to the Israelites about their forty years wandering in the wilderness. He says, “These forty years the Lord your God has been with you; you have lacked nothing.”
Older translations say, “You wanted for nothing.”
And in Hebrew, it’s the same word as in the psalm—chesar, if you like learning other languages.
And that word choice is really intentional, because it ties this psalm back to the earlier stories of Israel.
It would be like if, in American dialogue, someone used the phrase “certain inalienable rights.” We would immediately recognize that as a reference to the Declaration of Independence.
In the same way, this word is a reference back to their ancestors’ story.
So what the author of the psalm is saying here is: these times are not unprecedented. Just as God was with our ancestors back then, God is with us now. And just as they got through hard times then, we are going to get through this hard time now.
It’s the same story. It’s connected.
So when it says, “I shall not be in want,” that’s the first reason why this psalm is comforting.
Let’s move on.
“He makes me lie down in green pastures.”
This is another interesting image.
Sheep, as we know, are prey animals. And prey animals don’t survive by having big claws or being stronger than predators. They survive by hypervigilance—by watching all the time.
If you’ve ever seen a deer in a field, you know what that looks like.
Prey animals don’t lie down easily. Many animals, like cows, learn to sleep standing up so they can run quickly if a predator comes near.
They only lie down when they feel completely safe.
So when the psalm says, “He makes me lie down,” it’s describing that level of trust. That sense of safety.
Any cat people here? Dogs love belly rubs. Cats? Only if you are their very special person.
I have a cat who will let me rub her belly—but only after everyone else has gone to bed, and no one else is around. Then she decides, “Okay… now you can.”
Because that’s when she feels safe.
That’s the relationship being described here.
Let’s keep going.
“He guides me along right pathways.”
Again, something we might take for granted—but it’s referring to something very specific in shepherding culture.
The ancient Israelites were a shepherding people. Their ancestors worked the same land for generations. There were no paved roads, no GPS.
But over time, the safest routes through the wilderness became worn into the land. Paths formed by generations of shepherds who had learned where to go and where not to go.
So those “right pathways” are the collective wisdom of those who came before.
Which leads into the next verse:
“Though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I shall fear no evil; for you are with me; your rod and your staff, they comfort me.”
The shepherd’s staff—that crook—is a familiar image. Our bishops carry something similar as a symbol of their pastoral office. “Pastor” literally means shepherd.
That staff is a weapon—not to beat the sheep into submission, but to defend them. To fight off predators when necessary.
The wilderness is dangerous. So it’s comforting to know that the shepherd is with you, ready to protect you.
And then we come to this remarkable image:
“You spread a table before me in the presence of those who trouble me.”
Older translations say, “in the presence of my enemies.”
Picture this:
Two armies lined up on a battlefield, ready to charge.
And then one general strolls out into the middle of no man’s land… lays out a blanket… pulls out a basket of sandwiches and lemonade… and sits down for a picnic.
Can you imagine?
The enemy soldiers would be watching and thinking, “That guy has a lot of nerve. He’s either very brave or very foolish.”
There is nothing more unsettling to an opponent than someone who remains calm in the face of danger—who doesn’t panic, who doesn’t react, but simply holds their ground.
That is what faith looks like.
It looks like the audacity to have a picnic in the middle of a war zone.
Psalm 23 is comforting not because it describes perfect, peaceful surroundings, but because it describes a way of being—a kind of serenity—that can exist even when things are not safe.
That’s what it looks like to trust the Good Shepherd.
And the beautiful part is this:
When we trust the Good Shepherd, we begin to become the hands and feet of the Good Shepherd in the world.
We begin to offer that same sense of safety and care to one another.
This can take many forms.
It can look like bringing meals to someone who is sick—like so many of you did for my family this week when my wife had surgery. Thank you. She’s doing well.
It can look like offering rides to church.
It can look like creating a space where someone who is going through something hard can come, speak freely, and know they will be safe—that they will be held, metaphorically, in the arms of love.
All of these are ways we become the hands and feet of the Good Shepherd.
There’s another way I’ve been learning about over the past several years—something specific to my experience as a man—and I suspect many of my brothers here can relate.
My wife once asked me: if I were walking through a dark parking lot at night and saw another man walking nearby, what would I think?
And I said, “Honestly? I’d probably be thinking about what I need to get at Meijer.”
And she said, “My first thought would be: I hope he doesn’t attack me.”
That was eye-opening.
It made me realize that many of our sisters are navigating the world with concerns that have never even occurred to me.
And it made me start thinking: what are some simple ways I can be the hands and feet of the Good Shepherd?
Sometimes it’s very simple.
If you’re walking through a parking lot and there’s a woman a few steps ahead of you, you can slow down. Give her space.
You might just be thinking about eggs, milk, bread.
But she doesn’t know that.
So creating that space communicates something: safety, respect.
This isn’t about politics. It’s about what our mothers and grandmothers taught us about being gentlemen—literally, gentle men.
It costs us almost nothing. A few extra seconds.
But the impact is powerful.
It creates space. It communicates care.
It’s one small way we can walk those “right pathways”—those well-worn paths of respect, kindness, and gentleness.
There are many other ways. You can think of your own—I’ve seen you do them.
And I look forward to seeing the ways you continue to create spaces of safety and love in this community.
Spaces that reflect the care of our Good Shepherd.
Amen.
Hopping Hadrian's Wall 